Background
Our client is a Korean software company that delivers maintenance services on behalf of a U.S. provider. At an end customer's request, it signed a one-year maintenance contract with the customer's partner company. The contract renewed at the prior year's fee plus 5% unless either party gave written notice at least 90 days before expiry.
No notice came, so the contract renewed and the client paid the U.S. provider KRW 65,100,000 for the second year. The counterparty then sent three termination notices on shifting grounds, ending with the end customer's financial trouble. The client sued for the second-year fee of KRW 88,935,000.
What Was at Stake
The counterparty argued that the term ran from the signing date of a separate contract, that the renewal clause was an unfair standard term, that the customer's finances justified termination, and that performance had become impossible.
How Changchun LLC Helped
Law Firm Changchun LLC (Attorneys Woo-jin Kim, Je-sun Yoon and Hyun-woo Joo) obtained a provisional attachment of the counterparty's bank deposits and focused on four points.
The contract text. The term was fixed in the contract; a third-party contract could not change it.
No ground for termination. A non-party customer's finances did not match the listed grounds of agreement, breach, insolvency or legal impossibility.
A fair clause. The contract was individually negotiated, and the original vendor raises its own maintenance fees by 8% a year.
Readiness to perform. The client had already paid for the second year and stood ready to provide service.
Outcome
The first-instance court upheld the renewal clause and ordered the counterparty to pay KRW 88,935,000 plus late-payment interest and costs. The appellate court dismissed the appeal, and the judgment became final and conclusive.
Under an auto-renewing contract, the notice deadline and the listed termination grounds decide the case. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)