KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Limiting a Real Estate Broker's Liability to 40% in a Double-Lease Damages Claim

Background

Our client is a licensed real estate broker in Seoul. In July 2018, the client brokered a lease of a villa unit to a Seoul municipal housing corporation, which paid KRW 84.6 million of the KRW 90 million deposit. The owner's agent attended the signing with the owner's seal and a power of attorney.

Another tenant had already leased the unit and registered residence there (a double lease). The corporation won a judgment against the landlord for KRW 94.5 million in deposit and penalty, yet separately sued our client for KRW 84.6 million, alleging a failure to verify the prior tenant.

What Was at Stake

Did the broker breach the statutory duty to verify and explain? Did any loss remain despite the judgment against the landlord? And if liable, how far did liability extend?

How Changchun LLC Helped

Attorneys Dong-hwan Shin and Hyun-woo Joo argued that:

  • The impersonation was undetectable. The agent carried the seal and power of attorney, and the corporation's own one- to two-week screening found nothing.

  • Responsibility lay with the named landlord, who created the appearance of authority and could not shift it to a broker who relied on it.

  • The loss was already covered. The prior judgment entitled the corporation to KRW 94.5 million, more than the claim.

Outcome

The court found the broker negligent for not revisiting the unit to check occupancy and held that the judgment against the landlord did not erase the loss. However, because the corporation paid without inspecting the property itself and the real wrongdoers appeared to be others, the court limited our client's liability to 40%. Our client owed KRW 33.84 million (40% of KRW 84.6 million) plus delay interest, and the corporation bore half of the litigation costs. The judgment became final and conclusive.

Even where a broker is found negligent, the tenant's own lack of diligence and the identity of the actual fraudsters can significantly reduce exposure. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.