Background
Our client, a company employee, drank far beyond his limit at a restaurant. He then mistook a stranger's luxury sedan parked outside the restaurant for his own car and drove it using the key left inside. He was soon found asleep in the car, with a blood alcohol concentration well above the threshold for license revocation. The police investigated him for drunk driving and theft.
What Was at Stake
The drunk driving was not in dispute; the theft charge was. Theft requires an intent to treat another's property as one's own, and the surface facts looked damaging.
How Changchun LLC Helped
Attorney Ji-hye Hyun of Law Firm Changchun LLC submitted a defense opinion admitting the drunk driving but contesting any intent to steal.
Mistaken identity. A comparison with the car our client usually drove showed how he could have taken a similar car for his own.
His conduct at the scene. His movements on CCTV and the surrounding circumstances did not fit the behavior of someone stealing a car.
Mitigation. He had no criminal record and submitted apology and character letters. A settlement with the victim was also reached.
Outcome
Our client was charged not with theft but with unauthorized use of a motor vehicle and drunk driving. The court issued a summary order (a written procedure without a full trial) imposing a fine of KRW 5,000,000.
Even when a drunk driver takes someone else's car, the facts can separate theft from unauthorized use. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)