KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Clearing a Children's Activity Center of Child Neglect Allegations Over an Allergic Reaction

Background

Our clients were the operator of a hands-on activity center for young children and one of its class teachers. A child of about four, whose parents had reported an egg allergy in advance, began scratching during a cooking class.

The child's guardian filed a criminal complaint, alleging that the teacher had let the child touch a quail egg, causing an allergic reaction, and that our clients had then failed to care for the child, in violation of the Child Welfare Act.

What Was at Stake

The Child Welfare Act punishes neglect of a child under one's care and supervision. Because the child did develop symptoms, the question was whether our clients had abandoned that duty of care.

How Changchun LLC Helped

Law Firm Changchun LLC (Attorney Jihye Hyun) submitted a written defense opinion to the police, showing with evidence that our clients had not neglected the child but had taken every step available to them.

  • The child was kept out of the quail egg steps. Allergy information was checked twice, and the child was given milk instead of quail eggs and left out of cracking and mixing them. The child only briefly held an unbroken quail egg for a photo, yet the guardian claimed the quail egg caused the allergy.

  • An egg allergy is not a quail egg allergy. Hospital egg allergy tests have no separate quail egg item, and the two allergies are classified separately in medicine, as we showed with research on cross-reactivity and other materials. Photos also showed that 8 other children with reported egg allergies had touched or cooked with quail eggs during the same program without any problem.

  • The response after the symptoms. Based on CCTV footage, we showed that within about 2 minutes of noticing the symptoms, the teachers washed the child, handed the child over to the guardian, and helped find a nearby clinic.

Outcome

The police closed the case without referral to the prosecution.

A child's injury does not by itself establish neglect. Objective evidence of everyday safety practices and the immediate response can clear those responsible of the charge. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.