KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Limiting a KRW 97 Million Key Money Damages Claim to KRW 7 Million for a Prospective Commercial Tenant

Background

Our client, planning to open a shop, viewed a restaurant through a real estate agent and discussed with the sitting tenant key money (gwolligeum, a premium paid to an outgoing commercial tenant) of KRW 100 million. The client sent KRW 3 million, but days later withdrew, citing funding difficulties. No written contract was signed.

The tenant sued for KRW 97 million, the unpaid balance, as damages. Our client counterclaimed for the KRW 3 million.

What Was at Stake

The issues were whether talks and a payment alone formed a contract and, if so, how to measure the loss. The tenant later restated the claim: KRW 10 million for the drop in key money plus KRW 8.17 million in two months of rent and fees, totaling KRW 18.17 million, less KRW 3 million, for KRW 15.17 million.

How Changchun LLC Helped

Attorney Ji-hye Hyun argued that no contract was formed and, alternatively, that any loss must be measured narrowly.

  • Key money is not the loss. If the deal is rescinded, the shop's value stays with the tenant, so the loss is only the difference between the expected and remaining benefit.

  • Rent is unrelated. Rent and fees were owed under the tenant's own lease regardless of the deal.

Outcome

The first-instance court found a contract had been formed but limited the loss to KRW 10 million, the gap between KRW 100 million and the KRW 90 million paid by a new tenant, and rejected the rent claim for lack of causation. Deducting the KRW 3 million, it awarded KRW 7 million plus interest and dismissed the counterclaim. The appellate court dismissed both sides' appeals.

A key money deal can bind without a written contract, so terms should be settled before sending money. Yet a failed deal does not mean paying the full key money. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.