KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Snow-Damaged Neighbor's Tree Removed by Agreement: Police Close Property Damage Case Without Referral

Background

In late November 2024, heavy snow snapped a neighbor's willow tree about halfway up, and most of it fell over the boundary wall onto our client's land. Tenants asked for quick removal, citing blocked access and the risk of injury.

Both our client and the tree's owner were abroad. By phone, they agreed that our client's regular landscaper would work from our client's side of the wall and that the owner would pay the fee. After the work, however, the owner reported our client to the police for property damage, claiming five trees had been cut without permission.

What Was at Stake

Property damage requires intent, meaning awareness of harming another person's property. The question was whether our client, who had called in the landscaper, had that intent.

How Changchun Helped

Law Firm Changchun (Attorney Sung-joong Kim) submitted a written opinion to the police.

  • The work was agreed. Text and KakaoTalk messages showed that the owner consented to the landscaper and to work from across the wall, and that no limits on its scope were set.

  • The landscaper lacked intent. He cut two trees, judging that a tree broken in half could not survive. We cited decisions finding no intent where the owner approved the work, even if the cutting differed somewhat from the owner's wishes.

  • Our client did not know the result. Our client gave no specific instructions and learned the outcome only after the complaint. As the landscaper cut only two trees, our client could not have known of the other three.

Outcome

In February 2025, the police found insufficient objective evidence of intent and closed the case without referral (no suspicion), ending it without sending it to prosecutors.

Damage to property is not automatically a crime when work was entrusted to a professional with the owner's consent. Reconstructing the agreement from message records is key. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.