KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Recovering a Tenant's Full Down Payment After the Landlords Broke the Trust Underlying the Lease

Background

Our client signed a 24-month lease for the semi-basement unit of a multi-family house in Seoul, with a deposit of KRW 50 million and monthly rent of KRW 900,000. On the day of signing, our client paid a down payment of KRW 5 million to the landlords, a married couple who co-owned the building.

Four days later, the landlords asked our client to let a third party stay in the unit past the agreed move-in date. Later, they asked our client to allow a third party to register the unit as a residential address without living there, so that the third party's child could be assigned to a nearby school. Our client refused both requests and gave notice of termination. The landlords offered to return the down payment only after deducting a brokerage fee and two months' rent.

What Was at Stake

A down payment is usually forfeited by the party who walks away. The landlords argued that our client had chosen to end the contract and should bear part of the loss.

How Changchun Helped

Attorney Sung-joong Kim of Law Firm Changchun filed for a payment order (jigeup myeongryeong, a summary procedure for money claims) and made three points:

  • The landlords broke the trust first. Using call logs and text messages, Changchun laid out both requests by date. A false address registration could have weakened our client's ability to assert the lease against third parties.

  • The termination was therefore valid. Changchun relied on Supreme Court of Korea precedent allowing a lease to be ended when one party seriously betrays the trust underlying it.

  • Both landlords were liable. As co-landlords, their duty to return the payment could not be split between them.

Outcome

The court ordered the landlords to jointly return KRW 5 million to our client, the full amount of the down payment. Our client did not pursue the separate penalty claim, and the court's decision became final and conclusive.

When a landlord breaks the trust on which a lease rests, a tenant who ends the contract may still recover the full down payment. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.