Background
Our client, a semiconductor parts supplier, sold its business to an electronic components company in May 2020. The agreement set the business rights fee at KRW 4 billion (KRW 4.4 billion including VAT), payable over five years from 30% of the business's operating profit.
The buyer ran the business through a subsidiary and sold that subsidiary in October 2024. After paying approximately KRW 2,590.46 million in 11 installments, it argued the fee was an "earn-out" (a price tied to post-closing performance) whose payment period had ended.
What Was at Stake
The agreement said the fee "may be adjusted" and that a separate agreement would follow if less than KRW 4 billion had been paid after five years. Was KRW 4 billion a fixed price or merely a cap?
How Attorney Joo-hyun Park Helped
A stated sum. The agreement spelled out "four billion won," just as it fixed the other price items.
The separate-agreement clause. A shortfall clause would be pointless if the price simply equaled profits.
No earn-out terms. The agreement lacked the performance targets, verification procedures and resale provisions of a genuine earn-out.
A precise claim. Deducting approximately KRW 191.65 million paid mid-suit, the claim was reduced to approximately KRW 1,809.53 million.
Outcome
The first-instance court held that the fee was KRW 4 billion and the profit share merely set the payment method. It found that the buyer, by selling the business without a separate agreement, had refused cooperation in breach of good faith. The court ordered payment of the full approximately KRW 1,809.53 million (KRW 4.4 billion less approximately KRW 2,590.46 million paid) plus late-payment damages, which ran from the day after the hearings closed rather than September 2025; each party bore its own costs.
In installment-based sales, whether the total is a fixed price or a cap often decides the dispute. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)
Attorney Joo-hyun Park handled this case at a previous law firm before joining Changchun LLC.