Background
Our client was a public corporation with sites across several divisions. The plaintiff joined as a fixed-term worker in 2012 and, after a performance review, was converted in 2014 to a support-track fire safety officer on an open-ended contract.
The plaintiff argued that general-track employees at other divisions did the same fire safety work but were paid more. Citing the equal treatment rule in the Labor Standards Act and the equal-pay-for-equal-work rule in the Equal Employment Opportunity and Work-Family Balance Assistance Act, the plaintiff claimed approximately KRW 26.6 million in damages, the base-salary gap for 2023 to 2025.
What Was at Stake
The dispute turned on two questions: whether support-track status is a “social status” protected against discrimination, and whether support-track and general-track employees belong to the same comparison group.
How Attorney Joo-hyun Park Helped
Attorney Joo-hyun Park shifted the focus from whether the tasks were similar to whether the two job tracks were comparable in the first place.
Employment type is not a social status. The plaintiff entered the support-track contract voluntarily through a conversion process foreseen in the earlier contract, and remained free to apply for general-track hiring.
Different hiring, career, and pay structures. General-track staff are hired through written exams, interviews, and an internship, and are subject to promotion and rotation. Support-track staff hold a fixed role with no promotion ladder and no job-grade pay.
No targeting of the individual. Fire safety work was classified as a support-track role through a company-wide job evaluation that began before the plaintiff was hired.
Flawed damages calculation. Most of the claimed gap arose because the comparator employee was promoted in 2024.
Outcome
The first-instance court held that support-track status is not a social status and that the plaintiff was not in the same comparison group as general-track staff, whose fire safety assignments reflected routine rotation. It dismissed the claim in full and ordered the plaintiff to bear the litigation costs.
Performing the same tasks as another employee does not by itself establish pay discrimination. Employers can defend their personnel systems by documenting how each job track is designed. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)
This case was handled by Attorney Joo-hyun Park as lead counsel at a previous law firm before joining Law Firm Changchun LLC.