KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Defeating a Former Employee's Claim for Option Shares After Resigning Before the Exercise Window Opened

Background

Our client is a privately held company that makes and sells quasi-drugs. In April 2021 it granted an employee a stock option to buy 2,000 shares at KRW 11,500 per share, exercisable from April 1, 2024 to March 31, 2026.

The agreement allowed exercise within that window "while employed," and required a departing employee to exercise any "exercisable" option within 5 years of leaving. The employee resigned voluntarily at the end of February 2024, about one month before the window opened. In April 2026 the former employee gave notice of exercise and sued for delivery of the 2,000 shares.

What Was at Stake

The former employee argued that the exercise was valid because 5 years had not passed since departure. They also argued that the board resolution clearing the option, which used the word "cancellation," took away a right without any contractual ground for cancellation.

How Changchun LLC Helped

Law Firm Changchun LLC (Attorneys Jung-heon Park, Kyung-seok Park and Jong-hoon Kim) represented the company and argued that the clauses must be read as a single structure.

  • The word "exercisable" matters. The 5-year clause gives extra time only to those who leave after meeting the employment condition, with an option already exercisable.

  • The opposite reading is unreasonable. An employee who stayed to the end could exercise only until March 2026, while one who left early could exercise until February 2029.

  • The board resolution cancelled nothing. The option never took effect, so the resolution merely recorded and confirmed that fact.

Outcome

The first-instance court held that the 5-year clause applies only to those who met the employment condition, dismissed the claim in full, and ordered the plaintiff to bear the litigation costs. An appeal has been filed, so the judgment is not yet final.

Stock option disputes often turn on the structure of the whole agreement, not a single phrase. Companies should check how exercise conditions and post-departure clauses fit together. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.