KR EN
Global Legal Support Consultation
Cases

Defeating a KRW 2 Billion Defective-Construction Claim Against an Architect Who Conducted the Use-Approval Inspection

Background

Our client, an architect, was commissioned by a city government in Jeju to inspect a mixed-use building for use approval (the permit allowing a completed building to be occupied). In July 2023, the client reported the building fit for approval, and it was approved that month.

A later safety inspection found rebar missing inside some beams and columns. The developer, whose project had collapsed, sued the contractor, subcontractor, supervisor, site manager and our client jointly for KRW 2 billion. It alleged a false inspection report and approximately KRW 26 billion in lost expected profits, among other losses. Law Firm Changchun LLC represented only our client.

What Was at Stake

The issues were whether the report was false, whether the client was negligent, and whether the report caused the claimed losses.

How Changchun LLC Helped

Attorneys Jeong-heon Park and Ha-rim Choi separated the scope of the inspection from the real cause of the losses.

  • Hidden defects fall outside the inspection. The rebar was buried in concrete and surfaced only after a specialist spent more than two months on a precision safety inspection.

  • The report was not false. The city itself then held that the basement machine room needed no direct stairway; a corrective order came 15 months after the inspection.

  • Everyone treated the work as complete. The supervisor had certified the building, and the developer itself sent move-in notices and signed a completion certificate.

  • The losses had other causes. Sales contracts ended because buyers failed to pay, defect complaints came more than one year later, and another court found the developer still held its development rights.

Outcome

The first-instance court found no proof of a false report or of intent or negligence, and no causal link to the losses. It dismissed the claim against our client in full and ordered the developer to bear the related costs.

Conducting a use-approval inspection does not make an inspector liable for every defect in a building. (Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.)

Case articles are anonymized within the scope of client consent and are provided for general information only, not as legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the facts of each case.